February 9, 2025
In 1986 there was a severe drought in Israel. The level of water in the Sea of Galilee became quite low and a significant portion of the shoreline, normally underwater, was exposed. Two brothers who were avid amateur archaeologists were walking along the newly exposed shoreline looking for antiquities when they found first a few gold coins, then a few ancient nails, and then the oval outline of what proved to be a boat, buried in the mud: an intact boat. The Israeli Department of Antiquities was contacted and after working around the clock for 11 days, the boat was excavated. A combination of carbon dating and examination of a pottery oil lamp that was on board the boat dated the construction of the boat to 40 BCE, plus or minus 80 years. So, this boat could very possibly have been in use during the time of Jesus, and it does appear to have been a fishing boat, not at all unlike the one in our story today.
The recovered boat is 26 ½ feet long, 7 ½ feet wide, and 4 ½ feet high. The boat had seats, a small deck in the front and back of the boat, and at one time, it had a mast, so the boat could have been sailed or rowed. During the first century, fishing boats such as these would have carried a crew of five. The boat had enough room to hold up to 15 people or had the capacity to carry more than a ton of cargo. Hold that thought because this fact will become important later.
Our story today tells us that Simon (Whose name Jesus has not yet changed to Peter), along with James, and John were at the shore of the Sea of Galilee with their crews and their boats. (And to avoid confusion, I am going to call Simon “Peter” throughout my remarks today). They had had a long night of fishing and had caught nothing and were in the process of cleaning their nets. Now, first century fishing nets were made of linen. The net would be held between two boats and since fishing was best in shallow water, the nets would drag on the bottom of the lake. And so, these nets would pick up rocks, silt, and sticks that were in the water and since the fishing nets were the fishermen’s livelihood, they really had to be taken care of. So immediately after fishing, the rocks and sticks would be removed, any tears would be repaired, and then the nets would be rinsed, hung out to dry, and then folded and put away for their next use. It was a time-consuming process, but it had to be done before the fishermen could go home and get some rest after a long night’s work.
On this particular day, Jesus had come down to the Sea of Galilee and a large crowd had followed Him. Jesus was teaching the crowd, but as the crowd got larger and was pushing forward so they could hear His words, Jesus was being pushed towards the sea. Peter’s boat was there, and so Jesus boarded Peter’s boat and asked Peter if he would move the boat just a little offshore so Jesus could speak to the gathered crowd. There are places on the Sea of Galilee where the shore slopes steeply upward, creating a natural amphitheater. Today a tour of the Holy Land can take you to one of these places where a speaking voice can be heard by a thousand people or more. Jesus undoubtably took advantage of this phenomenon to allow His sermon to be heard by the crowd as He spoke
The first really interesting thing about today’s story is the fact that Luke does not mention any of the content of Jesus’ sermon; we have no idea what He was talking about that day. In today’s reading Luke is focused entirely on the interaction between Jesus and Peter. Now, lest we think that Jesus and Peter are strangers, in Luke 4:38-39, before today’s story took place, Jesus had been a guest at Peter’s home and had healed Peter’s mother-in-law of a high fever, so they were already acquainted, and possibly already friends.
But you know how some friends can sometimes ask the most inopportune things? Well, after He finished speaking, Jesus turned to Peter and asked him to take his boat out to the deep water and let down the nets. I am certain that Peter had several problems with this request. First of all, Peter, being a professional fisherman, knew that during the day the fish could see the nets and would just swim around them, and second, that fishing on the Sea of Galilee was always best in the shallow water, so what Jesus was asking him to do was actually kind of ridiculous. In addition to that, they had just gone through the laborious process of cleaning, mending, washing, and drying their nets and if they put the nets back into the water again, they would have to go through that whole process of cleaning them again, meaning it would be even longer before they were able to get home and get some rest after a long and very unsuccessful night of fishing.
I would imagine that it was with a mixture of exasperation and resignation that Peter said to Jesus, “Master, we’ve worked hard all night and haven’t caught anything. But because you say so, I will let down the nets.”
We all know what happened next. They caught so many fish that the nets began to break. Peter signaled to the other boat to join them to help gather together all of the fish that they caught, and the text tells us that they had so many fish that both boats began to sink. Now, do you remember the thought that I asked you to hold on to about the fishing boats? If the two of these boats were loaded so full that they began to sink, that means that they had just caught over two tons of fish. That’s a lot of fish.
Peter, the professional fisherman, recognized instantly that what had just happened was impossible. Peter, who had already seen one miracle when Jesus healed his mother-in-law, now knew that he had seen a second one, and it was a doozy.
Since I began preaching last March, I have been using the Lectionary. The Lectionary is a three-year cycle of weekly Bible readings designed to take you through all of the main themes of the Bible in those three years. Each week there is usually an Old Testament lesson, a lesson from the Psalms, a Gospel lesson, and an epistle lesson. The Lectionary readings do not always coordinate, but today they did. In our Old Testament lesson today about the calling of Isaiah, when Isaiah was confronted with the holiness of God, Isaiah said, “Woe to me! I am ruined! For I am a man of unclean lips, and I live among a people of unclean lips, and my eyes have seen the King, the Lord Almighty.” Isaiah was terrified. But after God reassured Isaiah, telling him not to be afraid, God asked Isaiah “Who shall I send?” Isaiah’s response? “Here am I, send me”.
When Peter was confronted with the holiness of God through Jesus’ miracle, Peter fell on his knees and said, “Go away from me, Lord; I am a sinful man!” After Jesus reassured Peter, telling him not to be afraid, Jesus told Peter that from now on, Peter would fish for people. Peter’s response? Peter left everything behind to follow Jesus. There seems to be a pattern here, don’t you think? John Calvin said, “It is evident that [humans] never attain to a true self-knowledge until [they] have previously contemplated the face of God and come down after such contemplation to look into [themselves]. [1] For Peter and Isaiah, as for us, the recognition of God’s holiness can cause us to view ourselves in an entirely different light.
The change in Peter was evident in how he chose to address Jesus. Before the miracle, Peter referred to Jesus as Ἐπιστάτα (Epistata) which we translate “master” and means to stand over or to be set over; in other words, an overseer or someone in authority. After the miracle, Peter refers to Jesus as Κύριε (Kyrie), “Lord”. It is a word that recognizes the divine authority of Jesus. Peter, having just seen the hand of God in Jesus’ miracle, left everything behind, and followed Jesus, just as Isaiah had done some 750 years earlier. This is the step in faith that God is asking us to take also. To set aside our feelings of unworthiness and inadequacy and to trust God implicitly that He will teach us, and lead us, and guide us. Pritchard said, “I find it significant that Jesus seems in a sense to ignore Peter’s desperate confession of unworthiness. Jesus knows the truth about Peter, and he knew it all along. What matters is that Peter now knows the truth about himself. With his pride stripped away, he is now ready to serve the Lord. [2]
And so, how do we fit into all of this? Let me ask a question. When Jesus asked Peter to do something that was, quite truly, a very foolish thing to ask, what would have happened if Peter had refused? What if Peter explained to Jesus why His request was so foolish and then packed up his nets and went home? Yes, God calls us, but His call requires a response from us as well. Peter DID let down the nets, and then he walked away from a two-ton catch of fish. This one catch alone was enough to make Peter and his associates financially comfortable. But he put it all behind him in order to become a servant of God. When Jesus said that He would make Peter a fisher of people, that was an understatement. In Acts 2 Peter boldly gave a sermon on the streets of Jerusalem and on that day alone 3,000 people became followers of Jesus, 3,000! Peter’s contributions to the church of Jesus Christ are pretty much immeasurable. But none of that would ever have happened had Peter not said to Jesus “But because you say so, I will”.
There is not a person in this room today, not a person joining us on Zoom today, who God hasn’t called. Johnson tells us that, “Jesus calls Peter and his partners as they are. Peter is acutely aware of his unworthiness, but Jesus is not put off by this in the slightest. Jesus does not ask Peter to get his act together, his resume prepared and then come back for an interview. Rather, Jesus encounters him as he is, tells him not to be afraid, and calls him to a new mission of catching people.” [3] God does not need for us to get our act together either. He encounters us as we are, and He asks us to follow Him and to become His servants as well. Pastor Brandon Moser says, “[God] didn’t call [us] because [we’re] perfect; He called [us] because He made [us] PERFECTLY for HIS purpose. [4] God is ready and eager to prepare us to do His work because God understands that within each of us is the capacity to make contributions to the Church of Jesus Christ that are immeasurable. Each of us has the capacity to touch the lives of others, each of us has the capacity to love others, to teach others, to touch others with the incredible Good News of the Gospel, and to make eternal differences in the lives of others. This is that to which we are called. And all of this is in our capacity to accomplish. All it takes is for us to say, “Because you say so, I will.”
[1] John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion, Chapter 1:2
[2] Ray Pritchard, KeepBelieving.com, The Frustrated Fisherman
[3] Elizabeth Johnson, WorkingPreacher.org, Great Catch of Fish
[4] Brandon Moser, Facebook Post: January 28, 1:00 PM