June 29, 2025
Luke 9:51-62
Josephus was the preeminent Jewish historian of the first century. In his book Antiquities of the Jews, Josephus tells the story of how badly the Samaritans treated Galilean Jews who were traveling from Galilee to Jerusalem. In Josephus’ account, so great was the animosity between the Jews and the Samaritans that not only were the Samaritans willing to accost and beat Jewish travelers on the road, but sometimes they would kill them. As a result of the dangers of this trip, most Jews traveled around Samaria, more than doubling the time of the trip from 3 days to 7 days. My guess would be that the hatred of these two groups of people towards each other is probably mirrored in the troubles that plague the Middle East today; a hatred that even 2,000 years ago was 1,000 years old.
And it is into this powder keg of hatred and bigotry that Jesus sends His disciples, asking them to arrange accommodations for Him and for His disciples as they travel through Samaria from Galilee to Jerusalem. Luke describes the result of this endeavor as the Samaritans “not receiving them”. That is probably a gross understatement, as I can’t imagine that the Disciples were not treated with derision and disrespect at best, and more likely with downright hostility. The Disciples return to Jesus to report on their experience, and James and John ask Jesus if He wants them to call down fire from heaven to destroy the Samaritan village that had just rejected them.
Now, let’s think about this, just for a minute. In the beginning of this chapter of Luke, Jesus sent the disciples out on their own where the disciples were given the power not just to preach, but to perform miraculous healings. They had witnessed the miraculous feeding of the 5,000. James and John were on the mountain with Jesus during the Transfiguration, where they had seen the glorified Jesus speaking with Moses and Elijah. It had been quite a week or so, don’t you think? And so, having personally witnessed the power of God working through Jesus and working through THEM, I don’t find it at all surprising that James and John believed that they could use God’s power to smite the offending village. Add to this the fact that James and John would have been aware off the fact that they were standing very near the site where Elijah had called down fire from heaven to incinerate not one, but two contingents of soldiers sent to him by the unfaithful king Ahaziah.
But I guess this fire from heaven idea from the disciples comes under the heading of “it seemed like a good idea at the time”. Luke doesn’t give any details at all, he simply reports to us that Jesus rebuked the brothers who made the offer. And in this rebuke, sparse though it may be, is a lesson that speaks to us today with every bit as much relevance as it did when Jesus spoke it to James and John, because at the core of the disciples’ attitudes lies a deep misunderstanding about the way that God has chosen to work through Jesus. A misunderstanding that is still very much in play today.
Maybe the disciples temporarily forgot about the woman at the well. Do we remember the story? Jesus comes to a well, in Samaria, and asks a Samaritan woman to draw some water for him to drink. This is a story that is confounding in several ways. The woman at the well was there in the heat of the day, women typically came in the morning before it became hot, but this woman came later because she was shunned by the community and wasn’t welcomed by the other women. Second, men did not just randomly speak to women that they did not know, and third, a Jew would not speak with, or even have any dealings with a Samaritan, but Jesus used this opportunity to identify Himself to the woman as the Messiah, and she became the first Samaritan evangelist. (And did anyone happen to notice that she was a woman? The modern church’s occasional reticence to place women in positions of authority didn’t come from Jesus. He was just fine with it. The church should be too!)
Or possibly the disciples also forgot about the parable Jesus told where the hero of the story wasn’t a Jewish priest or a Jewish Levite, but rather a despised Samaritan. If the disciples had taken the time to consider how Jesus had interacted with the Samaritans, they would have realized that, not only did Jesus not share their disdain for the Samaritans, but that Jesus was actively seeking to reach the Samaritans with the Good News that they also were loved by God.
Anyabwile tells us that, “In sinful, fallen anger the disciples want to call down judgment on people who have refused Jesus. That is not the Christian spirit. If people in the community reject Christ and us, we should not call for judgment. Judgment will come soon enough [and] that will be a great and terrible day. While it’s still day, our job is to announce the good news: There is a way to escape the coming judgment through repentance and faith in Christ. If they will not hear the good news, then in mercy we simply keep moving. Luke says, ‘They went to another Village’. They didn’t argue with the Samaritans. They didn’t look to destroy them. They left town. That was the merciful thing to do.” [1]
And so, here we have a cosmic shift in a very worldly attitude. Justice is an important part of who God is. And since we are made in God’s image, justice is an integral part of who we are as well. Humans, for the most part, long for justice. But as Jesus’ rebuke makes it clear, our vision of what constitutes justice doesn’t always necessarily align with God’s vision. In other words we need to understand and share God’s priorities, and foremost among those priorities is for mercy always to temper justice. Even though the Samaritans were spiteful and unwelcoming, they are STILL God’s beloved children, and it is still God’s desire to reconcile as many of them as will receive Him to Himself.
Unfortunately, we don’t have to look very far today to see the church of Jesus Christ calling down fire from heaven. We see it in the treatment of those who think differently. We see it in the treatment of those who worship differently. We see it in the treatment of those who love differently, or who behave differently, or who respond to personal difficulties in ways with which we don’t agree. And while it takes a little honesty on our parts, it doesn’t take much effort to see how those upon whom the fire is being called down can be easily hurt by it.
And I believe that this is the essence of Jesus’ rebuke. If the disciples had been permitted to destroy the village as they asked, the resulting fire would not just have consumed those who had been inhospitable, it would have affected the entire village, women, children, and even those who may have made the choice to BE hospitable had they been given the opportunity. And worst of all, after Pentecost, when the gospel spread through Samaria like, well… wildfire, those who had perished would never have had the opportunity to hear the Gospel. Priorities.
Chelsea Harmon tells us, “Being Jesus’s disciple isn’t about the power you get to wield over people, it’s about having the powerful presence of Christ within you, empowering you to be more and more like him. With Jesus’s face set toward Jerusalem, the disciples will soon see—even without fully understanding—how Jesus uses his power and how he treats those who reject him.” [2]
Today’s Gospel lesson is a call to be merciful. Today’s Gospel lesson is a call to be Christ-like; to follow His example and to adopt His priorities. It’s a call to understand that judgement is not our job. John 3:16-17, “For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son, that whoever believes in him shall not perish but have eternal life. For God did not send his Son into the world to”… What? “To CONDEMN the world, but that the world might be saved through him.
If our calling as Christians is to be Christ-like, then we also have not been sent into the world to condemn the world. We are here to bear witness to the one through whom the world will be saved. Chelsea Yarborough tells us that, “Jesus reminds us that allowing [others the freedom to choose] is a crucial practice of love. [Jesus] wanted to [stay in that Samaritan town], and yet [the choice of the Samaritans] was honored and respected. ?What was not celebrated and seen as a good choice? The choice to punish, to harm, to destroy in the name of Jesus because the disciples were inconvenienced or thought another choice should have been made. Jesus shows us that allowing space for another to have [the freedom to choose] is crucial to a life of love.” [3] My dear friends, we are not called to judge, we are called to love.
Whenever we feel like we want to be calling down that fire we need to be asking ourselves “what will be the result of our actions?” Our Epistle lesson today introduces us to the fruits of The Spirit. Paul tells us that when we are being faithful our actions will result in love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. These are the attributes around which God’s kingdom is built. Someday judgment will come, we all know that. But we also know that God, and God alone is able to judge rightly. So, let’s leave that job to Him.
Our text today ends with three short vignettes. In each one, someone professes their interest in following Jesus, and yet to each one Jesus calls out their reservation about following Him and is bluntly honest about what the call to discipleship means.
When I was a kid, growing up in Ohio, my family belonged to a pool club. I was there pretty much every day that it didn’t rain and I loved the place. They had a great concession stand, they had tennis courts and a miniature golf course, but probably the best feature was a huge slide that would send you skidding across the water. And I mean, this slide was epic! Can we show a picture of the slide?

But there was one thing about this slide… once you took that first step up the ladder, that was it, there was no going back. There was a long line to use that thing, so with every step you took there was another person getting on the ladder behind you, and they weren’t going to let you go back down, so once you start climbing, that’s it you’re going to go down that slide whether you want to or not. And yes, for those who are wondering, I went down it A LOT.
In the 2nd half of our reading today we find Jesus telling His prospective disciples that once you truly choose to follow Him, you are committed. No excuses, no trying to climb back down that ladder. When we choose to follow Jesus our lives are filled with new meaning. No longer are we only about ourselves. We are now about bringing to others that which has been given to us. The joy, the peace, the fellowship, the fulfillment of knowing that we are loved by God. These are the things that we are called to share with the world. THIS is our calling! Not to bring judgment, not to be calling down fire, but to bring grace, healing, forgiveness, and yes, love.
For those who share the heart of Jesus, for those for whom the Sprit has made us one with God, in Jesus, and through the Holy Spirit, there is no room for calling down fire from heaven. There is no fruit of the Spirit that will result from that fire. There is no heart that is likely to be turned towards God from that fire. But do you know what will be heard? Love.
[1] Thabiti Anyabwile, Exalting Jesus in Luke, Pg. 171
[2] Chelsea Harmon, https://cepreaching.org/commentary/2025-06-23/luke-951-62-4/
[3] Chelsea Brooke Yarborough, https://www.workingpreacher.org/commentaries/revised-common-lectionary/ordinary-13-3/commentary-on-luke-951-62-10