I’d like to make a theological observation about abortion. Let me please begin by saying that I am not a professionally trained theologian. I am a committed follower of Jesus Christ with a healthy curiosity and a penchant for reading… a lot. I believe Karl Barth was right when he said “In the church of Jesus Christ there should be no non-theologians” so I have put a lot of time into reading and studying the Bible with the help of a myriad of books and commentaries.
By the time I am done, I will probably irritate both the pro-choice AND the pro-life crowds so I humbly request the following: 1. Please do not bother to comment if you haven’t read the entire essay. 2. I welcome thoughtful theological comments, whether or not they agree with my position but I have taken great pains to limit this essay to theological thought. As such, I have no interest in political rhetoric. Partisan comments will be summarily deleted.
Shortly after becoming a Christian I attended classes and became certified as a lay speaker in the United Methodist Church. Over the years I have enjoyed the occasional turn in the pulpit and my agreement with my current (Presbyterian Church USA) church is that I will gladly fill the pulpit any time the pastor is away as long as someone else doesn’t want a turn. I generally preach 4-5 times a year.
One of the first sermons I ever preached was from the book of Habakkuk. As a young Christian the book appealed to me as a rather tidy lesson about God’s ways not being our ways. In a nutshell, Habakkuk complained to God about injustice in Judah. God replied that He was about to use Babylon to judge Judah. Habakkuk, aghast, asks how God could possibly use Babylon “That ruthless and impetuous people” to judge God’s chosen. God essentially answers Habakkuk by saying “Who do you think you are to question me”. The book ends with Habakkuk singing a song of praise to God. Babylon carries Judah into captivity, 70 years later a faithful remnant returns, rebuilds Jerusalem and the temple, and sets the stage for the coming of Christ. Nice, right?
This year I preached on Habakkuk for the second time. This time my sermon was informed by a great deal more study, including reading the work of Habakkuk’s contemporary Jeremiah. The book of Lamentations is the only book in the Bible that I have read and studied only once. I couldn’t bear to study it again. The Babylonian siege of Jerusalem was horrific, and without going into the ugly details, suffice it to say that many good and faithful Jewish people suffered… horribly. The lesson to be learned from Habakkuk goes much deeper than God’s ways not being our ways. In the book of Habakkuk, God is calling us to completely change our perspective and look at the world through heavenly eyes, rather than looking at the world through earthly eyes. Habakkuk, and we, are called to trust God when, from a worldly standpoint, He appears to be the least trustworthy. How am I supposed to trust in God’s goodness when the Bible says “Compassionate women cooked their children, who became food” (Lamentations 4:10)? How can I trust a God who allows such a thing to happen?
Our earthly eyes tell us that the suffering and death of the righteous is an abomination; it’s something that should never happen. But you and I both know that it does, and it does so with regularity. Are we to assume that, because this happens, God is not good? How are we to interpret events when the outcome is inconsistent with our concept of “Good”? The believer interprets these events not with earthy eyes, but with heavenly eyes. We learn to view events from God’s perspective. Francis Chan has this wonderful message where he has this enormous piece of rope that he carries out onto the chancel. There is a little short piece of tape on the end of the rope, and he uses the short piece of tape to represent our lives here on earth with the huge length of rope representing the eternity that we can’t see. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jF_x8dsvb_4) Our lives are not about this earth. We are foreigners here; ambassadors. Our kingdom and our destiny is the eternal Kingdom of our Lord, and of His Christ. As such, we are called to view the events of this life according to their eternal significance and to view death not as an end, but as a transformation, and for the believer, a joyous one at that.
To the person looking at a crisis pregnancy with earthly eyes, there are two possible outcomes. Either the baby lives or the baby dies. If we look at the crisis pregnancy with earthly eyes, for the baby to die is an unspeakable tragedy and for the baby to live is success.
Look at a crisis pregnancy with heavenly eyes however, and we see that there are not two but four possible outcomes. In the worst case scenario, the baby dies and the mother is so adversely affected by the experience that she never finds God’s grace and forgiveness. This is truly the greatest tragedy, because now we are dealing with an event that has eternal consequences. With our heavenly eyes we know that the baby, unborn and innocent, has a secure place in God’s Kingdom, but the mother is lost. Without somehow finding God’s forgiveness, she will be eternally separated from God’s love and care. In what might be a better scenario, the baby lives, but the mother is still adversely affected by the experience and never finds forgiveness. Bearing in mind the uncomfortable fact that a mother, antagonistic to Christianity, is highly likely to pass that antagonism on to her children, and you understand why I say it MIGHT be a better scenario, because now we are possibly dealing with two events of eternal significance. In the third scenario, the baby dies but the mother, cared for with grace and compassion throughout her ordeal, finds God’s grace, finds God’s forgiveness, and becomes a child of God’s Kingdom. With our heavenly eyes, we see that we now have two people who have entered into God’s eternal Kingdom. In the perfect scenario, the baby lives and the love of Jesus, exemplified by those who have ministered to the mother in her time of need, leads her to a saving faith, and hopefully to her child as well.
Let me be clear. More than once in the Bible God says “Before you were formed in your mother’s womb, I knew you”. Every living being is ordained by God and there can be no theological question in my mind that an unborn child is an ordained part of God’s kingdom. To take the life of an unborn child is, theologically speaking, taking a life… period.
But as one looking at the world through heavenly eyes, we know that free will is a central part of God’s eternal plan. Each of us has been given the capacity to choose whether we will love God, or whether we will reject Him. CS Lewis once said “Free will, though it makes evil possible, also makes possible any love or goodness or joy worth having. Only through the expression of our free will can we truly love God. As believers we must understand this. The Bible says that Jesus came into the world not to condemn the world, but that the world might be saved through Him. As emulators of Christ, it is our responsibility not to tell others how to behave, but to tell others about the riches to be found in a saving relationship with Christ Jesus.
There are two people who were mass murderers who went to prison. Our earthy eyes tell us these people are the dregs of humanity, but in prison both became Christian and both have borne tremendous fruit for the Kingdom. God forgave them and God used them and our heavenly eyes rejoice in their salvation and the fruit they have borne. Mark 3:28-29 says “Truly I tell you, people can be forgiven all their sins and every slander they utter, but whoever blasphemes against the Holy Spirit will never be forgiven; they are guilty of an eternal sin.” Of course without repentance there is no forgiveness, but when one repents, God is willing and indeed eager to forgive ANY sin. Only the sin of rejecting Him is unforgivable. Forgiveness of all other sin, however, is a private matter between the individual and God. Each of us is called to “Work out our own salvation with fear and trembling” (Phil 2:12b) If God is willing to forgive any sin, should we, who have been blessed with forgiveness and given a set of heavenly eyes, be any less willing? Our focus needs to be not on items of earthly significance, but on items of eternal significance. Uncomfortable though it may be, we must allow each of God’s children to make their own choices in this world and we must make our focus the heavenly focus of being God’s voice and bringing the Gospel to an unbelieving world.
I believe that the church should take a stand against evil. But I believe our stand should be one of offering an alternative of love, compassion, and forgiveness; a stand that uses heavenly eyes and produces results of eternal significance.